Noelle Winslow has the perfect life or so it seems from the outside. A small town Pastor's daughter, with a secret she's kept even from herself.

Then she meets Mae Kingsley, an out and proud lesbian at a school that doesn't exactly celebrate diversity. Her love life is a disaster with her toxic ex and her budding crush on the poster child of heterosexuality.

Can they keep up appearances when partnered together for the school play? Or will their secrets be revealed.